Friday, 4 January 2013


Aussie Mixed Bag posts are something I started when we began this blog - it’s a way for me to share some short reviews of a couple of Aussie books. These are all books I read earlier in the year, but never got around to posting my reviews. Seeing as the AWW Challenge for 2012 is over, I'm playing catch up and posting three reviews together.




Red by Libby Gleeson
Published May 2012 by Allen & Unwin
Source: the library
Rating: 3 paws


From the blurb: Mud. In her mouth, her nose, her eyes. Mud in her hair and caked on her neck and her arms. Mud filling her shoes and seeping through her clothes. She coughed, spat, tried to clear her throat."What's your name?" the voice said againRed can't answer. She can't remember the cyclone. She doesn't remember her name, where she lived, who her family might be. What can she do to find out who she is and where she belongs?Is there anyone she can trust to help her?

Red by Libby Gleeson is set in Sydney after a cyclone has destroyed most of the coastal suburbs. A girl wakes up and has no recollection of who she is but a boy nearby lets her tag along with him. Peri has been living on his own, even before the cyclone, but is very guarded about his past. Together they try and piece together what happened to her, and he nicknames her Red because of her t shirt.

Libby is a well known Australian author and I was sure I’d read other books of hers but looking at the list of them now it seems I haven’t. I’m not sure what I expected from this book, there was just something about the cover that appealed to me and I love a book set in Sydney but this turned out to be aimed a lot younger than I thought it would be. Red is only eleven or twelve years old and I have a feeling this is older middle grade as opposed to YA.

It was an interesting idea to combine a realistic story with a cyclone in Sydney (something that probably wouldn't ever happen here) as well as the story of what happened to Red and her father and who they are running from. The story moved at a good pace though there were quite a few coincidences that stood out to me but overall I enjoyed the story and felt it was wrapped up well.



Halo by Alexandra Adornetto
Published 2010 by Harper Collins Australia
Source: audio book borrowed from the library
Rating: 1 paw

From the blurb: Three angels – Gabriel, the warrior; Ivy, the healer; and Bethany, the youngest and most human – are sent by Heaven to bring good to a world falling under the influence of darkness. They work hard to conceal their luminous glow, superhuman powers, and, most dangerous of all, their wings, all the while avoiding all human attachments.Then Bethany meets Xavier Woods, and neither of them is able to resist the attraction between them. Gabriel and Ivy do everything in their power to intervene, but the bond between Xavier and Bethany seems too strong.The angel’s mission is urgent, and dark forces are threatening. Will love ruin Bethany or save her?

Halo by Alexandra Adornetto is set in the fictional town of Venus Cove. Three angels, Bethany, Gabriel and Ivy are sent to Earth to help quell dark forces that are causing all the problems occurring in our world. They are to be friendly to humans but never get too close and everything is fine until Beth meets Xavier Woods, a class mate at the high school she enrols in.

It feels odd including this book as I have now heard that the author left Australia for the US a few years ago but I wasn't aware of that when I started this book. I started listening to the audio book on my way to and from work, mainly because I was curious about how bad this book could actually be. The first thing that stuck me was the accents that Alexandra did for the reading. I thought she was putting these American accents on and they sounded too fake and were annoying. Now I suppose she does actually have an American accent but at the time I found it a bit distracting.

At first I didn't think this was going to be so bad story-wise. Yes it seemed ridiculous that instead of being sent to a war-torn country, three angels end up in a little beach-side town and their mission is to attend school, either as a student or a teacher, and to encourage people to go to church and have faith and support their community. That’s all fine but the cynic in me thought they were wasting their time.

Bethany, and her brother and sister, are also really judgemental. They want to look after humans but at the same time they look down on them. Bethany thinks her fellow students are stupid and shallow and judges the girls for sunning their legs at lunch time – oh my! But at the same time she ends up getting caught up in wanting to look perfect for the prom just for Xavier Woods so she ended up being as shallow as her friends. I thought Xavier Woods was ok at first but when he and Beth discuss having sex and he decided for her that she was not ready, he showed how controlling and overly protective he was. Ag.

The insta-love was pretty intense. Once Beth and Xavier Woods get together they are always with each other and Beth neglects her mission and other activities to spend all her time with him. She also cannot function without him to the point where she thinks it’s too hard to even breathe when they are no longer together. Double ag.

A character introduced later, Jake Thorn (who must always be referred to by his full name, this goes for Xavier Woods, too), really started to get to me and ended up being such a stereotypical caricature of an English boy. The accent was really annoying to listen to and I found every sentence he uttered made me roll my eyes, it was all so cheesy. And none of the even suspect he’s bad - Gabe and Ivy are meant to be fierce warriors but both are powerless against him and decide to wait until higher powers decide what to do rather than act now and stop a murderer.

I wasn't going to mention the religious aspect but it really felt preachy and it wasn't something I could ignore. Most angel books don’t go into as much detail regarding God/Heaven/Hell but this book did focus on it a lot and seemed to send the message that if we all just went to church more often, everything would magically be ok.

There was also a lot of repetition:  there are many, many descriptions of eye colour, the way hair flops into Xavier Woods' eyes, how good angels are at everything (yet Bethany is still a ditz) and just too many descriptions in general.

So this ended up being a full length review but it’s mainly just ranting and I really didn't want to dedicate a whole post just for this book. I definitely won’t be subjecting myself to the rest of the series.




Mercy by Rebecca Lim
Published 2010 by Harper Collins Australia
Source: purchased
Rating: 3 paws

From the blurb: Mercy ′wakes′ on a school bus bound for Paradise, a small town where everyone knows everyone else′s business... or thinks they do. But Mercy has a secret life. She is an angel, doomed to return repeatedly to Earth, taking on a new ′persona′ each time she does, in an effort to resolve a cataclysmic rift between heavenly beings. 

Mercy by Rebecca Lim is set in the fictional town of Paradise. Rebecca's an Aussie author and while the book does have a bit of an Aussie feel to it, it's never acknowledged as being the country where the book is set.

Mercy is a fallen angel. She's been exiled from heaven due to an incident but she can't remember what happened. Now she lives on Earth, inhabiting the bodies of humans, she never knows how long she'll be in one body. She'll be living in them, controlling their speech and actions and the next day she will awake in another person.

This time she finds herself in the body of a young girl called Carmen, on a bus to the town of Paradise where Carmen is going to visit another school and participate in their choir performance. Carmen is billeted with a family that has gone though a tragedy. Lauren Daley was kidnapped one night, two years ago leaving behind her older brother, Ryan and her parents. Mercy can sense the emotions of humans and this feeling is intensified by contact and she can tell the parents are still distraught. Ryan on the other hand is determined to find Lauren and hasn't given up hope that she is still alive. He's had strong feelings and visions of her and believes she's alive, possibly being held captive in a church.

Mercy decides to help Ryan track Lauren down and figure out who took her. They start investigating and focus on local churches and people who knew Lauren. I knew who the kidnapper was the moment we were introduced to them and thought Mercy should have been able to figure it out way before she finally realises.

Mercy is a very strong-willed character who's aggressive, blunt and extremely judgemental of the people around her, especially their physical appearance. She grew on me eventually because she does try to help the people she inhabits and she went out of her way to assist Ryan.

It took me a while to get into this book and even then I kept putting it down because I found it wasn't holding my attention. Because there's a lot that Mercy doesn't know or remember, as a reader I found I had so many questions that I knew weren't going to be answered. I wanted to know what happened to Mercy and who is controlling her now? She dreams of someone called Luc, who is he and can he be trusted? Is she ever going to find out who she really is and return to being an angel?

I always start reading an Aussie book thinking it's going to be excellent so I was disappointed that this fell short for me, I know a few other bloggers have really enjoyed it so don't let me feelings put you off. I do want to read the next book in the series because I really would like to know if the answers are revealed so I'll be checking that out soon.

These reviews are part of the Australian Women Writers 2012 Reading and Reviewing Challenge (the 2012 Challenge is now over, but you can sign up for the AWW 2013 Challenge here!)





23 comments:

Keertana said...

I've heard so many disappointing things about Halo, so I'm not surprised you have that one star. It's a shame that Mercy kept losing your attention, but I'm glad you still liked both it and Red. I hope you find some truly mind-blowing reads soon, though, Mandee! Wonderful reviews, dear! :)

1girl2manybooks said...

I bought Halo for the fabulous cover but then I began hearing how horrible it is and it's sat on my shelf unread ever since. And probably will for the rest of days.

roro said...

aww . all less than 5 paws

gr8 posts

Jasprit said...

I had the same sort of issues that you had with Halo too, it had too many eye roll moments for my liking! I've had my eye on Mercy for sometime too, but not really sure whether it would be my sort of read, I've only had a bit of luck with angel books so far. I think out of the three, Red would be the most appealing book to, the author has definitely tried something different here. Sorry these books weren't up to your liking as you'd hoped. But fab mini-reviews! :)

Danielle said...

Yeah, I've never had any great urge to read Alexandra Adornetto. Now I definitely won't.

Nice reviews :)

Erin W. said...

I LOVED Mercy but as for Halo . . . well let's just say we didn't get along all too well. It was WAY too preachy for my taste. I mean, the series did get better with its other two sequels but it was still too preachy and I didn't like that one bit. Anyway great reviews!

Sonia said...

Aww, sorry none of these were great reads for you :( I've been meaning to read Mercy for a while but I think I've only read like one positive review for Halo out of like 30 :P Red definitely sounds like it has an interesting premise, maybe I'll check that one out! Thanks for the great reviews, Mandee :)

Alex (A Girl, Books, OtherThings) said...

Oh, lord, that Halo book certainly gets a lot of bad rep from a lot of bloggers I trust, luckily I just don't feel like reading it - though it's a shame that cover was so pretty.

AnywayThe other books sound okay enough though!

Candace said...

I haven't heard of the first book but Halo was one I had for ages but felt no desire to read. I think initial reviews turned me off it. I recently gave it away and it sounds like I didn't miss anything. Mercy has also had mixed reviews and I kind of marked it off my list. At least you kind of liked it and didn't hate it though.

Shooting Stars Mag said...

Thanks for the reviews! I'm sorry these all fell a bit short for you. None of them really stick out as something I'd be interested anyway, so I guess it's good to know you didn't like them either. I don't remember reading another review of Halo but I DO recognize it from around. Bummer it's not that good. I think the preachiness about religion would bother me too.

The Teen Book Guru said...

Eh Halo seems SO weird! Definitely not picking it up... unless I want a good laugh. :P I read Mercy a long time ago, and if I remember correctly I think I quite enjoyed it! It certainly had its faults but it was okay. And Red seems pretty good too! I'll look for it next time I go to the bookstore. Great post and awesome mini reviews, Mandee! I love this feature! :)

Leanne said...

Hmm, I'm definitely going to pass on Halo, especially with all those scathing reviews I've seen and your single paw review. Mercy and Red both sound intriguing based on the premise albeit a bit disappointing. I completely understand though about an "Aussie feel" to books ~ I've been thinking about it, and many great authors such as Melina Marchetta, Laura Buzo, Cath Crowley etc. all have this Aussieness feel to their setting and prose. Too bad Rebecca Lim and Libby Gleeson didn't really..

Fabulous mini reviews, Mandee! :)

Belle said...

Steering clear of Halo, that's for sure! I haven't come across one single person who likes it.

Maja (The Nocturnal Library) said...

I never ever had any intention of reading Halo, but your review just cemented that decision. And wait, did I understand correctly that she read her own audiobook? Well, that is strange, at least in YA. Anyway, I've been tempted to read Mercy, but I think I'll pass anyway.
Thanks for the reviews. It's somehow comforting to know that not all Aussie books are perfect.

alexandrasscribblings said...

Ahh, I had all the same problems with Halo as you did. It had such a slow start too - which probably should have tipped me off that this was not the book for me - and Bethany and Xavier (Woods) are nauseatingly cutesy together. And the preachiness was pretty bad. I was more annoyed by the way Bethany would launch into this long monologue about heaven/angels/destiny and then break off with the comment that "such things are much too big for your small mortal mind to comprehend, of course". Patronising much?
But the cover really is gorgeous.

Tanja - Tanychy said...

From the books mentioned above I've only heard about Halo and honestly I'm not surprised by your review. A lot of people said the same thing about it so I decided to stay away from it :) While I'll check Mercy and Red :) Great reviews :)

Heidi@Rainy Day Ramblings said...

Halo is a book that I cannot see why people are still reading that series. I have read so many bad reviews of it and I don't think I have ever seen you give a one paw rating until now. You just reconfirmed why I am not going to read this one. I have been curious about Mercy, though.

australianbookshelf said...

I haven't heard of any of these Aussie books! I can see why you put off writing the reviews though Mandee, it's difficult writing reviews about books that disappointed us. Hopefully you'll pick up some great Aussie titles in 2013!

Bailey said...

Man I am so glad to see I am not the only one who didn't enjoy Halo. It seemed like it would be a great book but...I just could not get into it at all. But I have seen some people saying they really loved it. I read it a few years back and was considering giving it another chance...but after reading your review it reminds me why I didn't particularly enjoy it.

Sharon ObsessionwithBooks said...

I have been curious about Mercy and have had Halo on my book shelf for ages but I have avoided it because of the negative reviews, I think I'll definitely steer clear now.

Thanks for sharing your honest reviews.

Margaret Skipper said...

Wow that kitty to soo cute! Looks like s/he has a lot of reading to do! :D

Margaret @ alove4lit.blogspot.com

April (BooksandWine) said...

LOL Halo. Oh, that book. I was so excited for it and I read an ARC and everything and felt so alone when everyone else loved it and I hated it. Thank goodness I'm not alone in that feeling anymore. Oh my goodness, I just remember thinking that whole book was totally ridiculous and unenjoyable.

thesideofwonder said...

Interesting, I am reading Mercy for my AWW2013 challenge. I didn't know anything about it when I put it on my list and yours is the first review I've read. It sounds like an interesting concept, not something I would normally pick up and read, but good to give everything a go!

BEA 2013

BEA 2013
Mandee is attending!

Follow this blog with bloglovin

Follow on Bloglovin

Ladies of YA Podcast

Ladies of YA Podcast
Joins us for tea & book chat!

Rating Guide

5 paws = LOVED it
4 paws = really liked it
3 paws = liked it
2 paws = didn't like it
1 paw = really didn't like it/not for me/couldn't finish

Followers

Bloglovin' followers

Follow on Bloglovin

Bookish Blogs We Love

Grab our blog button!

Grab our blog button!

AWW 2013 Challenge

AWW 2013 Challenge
Read books by Aussie women!

Blog header by My Zoetrope

Preloved Blog Tour April 2012

Powered by Blogger.

Labels

Search

Loading...